India Taxpayer - India's Independent grassroots movement for better services and lower taxes

+91 422 254 0710

India Tax Payer, No.81, West Venkatasamy Road,R S Puram, Coimbatore - 641 002,Tamilnadu.

India Tax Payer Logo

Merchandise

Forum

Benefits

Resources

News

Event

About Us

  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • BENEFITS
  • RESOURCES
  • NEWS
  • FORUM
  • CONTACT US
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • BENEFITS
  • RESOURCES
  • NEWS
  • FORUM
  • CONTACT US

News & Events

Comments and Suggestions on Repowering of Wind Turbines.

Irena Markovic

 

 

 

Ref: TNERC/2019/04

 

 

Date: 26 Nov 2019

 

 

Tamil Nadu  Electricity Regulatory Commission,

Egmore

Chennai - 600008.

 

Hon’ble Commission,

 

Ref: Petition filed under section 62 (1) (a), 63 and 86 (1) (b) of the Electricity Act, 2003 – Comments and Suggestions on Repowering of Wind Turbines.

 

We, the Taxpayers of India, thank you for giving us this opportunity to present our comments on the above petition.

 

We would like to record the great appreciation that we have, on the wonderful services that TNERC has been spearheading in the last one and a half decades of Electricity business in this state of Tamil Nadu. Not to mention the yeoman service TNERC has done in bringing a huge Wind investment into the state of Tamil Nadu to make it the number one state in the country.

 

Most of the systems and processes that TNERC introduced in Tamil Nadu, have been adopted across the nation and the world. WE APPRECIATE ALL OF THIS AND MORE, IN NO SMALL MEASURE.

 

Perspective:

 

 

1.    Wind is renewable source of energy and is a preferred source because of its low carbon footprint. Citizens, tax payers and common people of this country will benefit by using such a source of power.

 

 

 

 

Comments:

1.       As per the Clause 4.0 for Type 1 (B) on Repowering WEG’s not exceeding the installed capacity in the petition:

 

WEG’s under wheeling agreements, it is proposed to adopt the Wind Energy Tariff Order No.6 of 2018, dt: 13.04.2018 for wheeling and banking since all the repowered WEG’s are considered as new WEG’s as per the MNRE guidelines. And so the banking of one month with encashment of unutilized energy at 75% of Tariff at the end of the month is proposed.

 

Our suggestions:

The earlier order in this regard for unutilized banked energy with encashment was fixed at 75%. However, our study on your earlier orders also do not explain the reason for reducing the rate to 75%. There being no clear sanctity for reduction of the rate by 25%. Therefore, we request you to retain the same at 100% of the FIT rate applicable to the generators.

 

2.  As per Clause 4. Generation, it is proposed that the generators under PPA with DisCom can continue being with them at the latest tender discovered rate and those under wheeling can continue to do so with the tariff structures as already decided by the Honorable Commission.

 

Our suggestions:

As per MNRE guidelines, all the repowered WEG’s are considered to be new WEG’s. Hence, the generators may choose between PPA and Wheeling agreement. If the generators are willing to supply to TANGEDCO at the tender discovered rate, then TANGEDCO may choose to sign the PPA irrespective of, whether the generator was under PPA or wheeling agreement earlier. Similarly, even if the generator is in the PPA, he may be given the option to choose either of the options.

 

So the clause 4. Generation. C. may be added thus.

“4. Generation.

            C. The generator may choose either PPA or wheeling agreement and sign the respective agreements on acceptance of the Distribution Licensee at the tariffs mentioned in Clause A and B”.

 

3.  Clause 4. Type II on Repowering WEG’s exceeding the installed capacity has indicated that if there is a delay in connectivity, the generator is not eligible for any compensation whatsoever.

 

Our suggestions:

We suggest the addition of the following clauses:

1.    Every communication to the Distribution Licensee should be appropriately acknowledged and replied to within 15 working days, where applicable. If there is no response from the Licensee for more than 15 days for a permission / license / rights, then it would be treated as granted.

2.    Distribution Licensee shall be given the option to establish an entity for an equivalent Gas based power generation or power storage system for power smoothening and grid stabilisation, in line with the increase in wind power generation. And the generators shall be requested to hold shares as investments, in such a power generation system that will run during lean wind season, thereby, nullifying the low generation. Cost of the system can be apportioned on the generators and they will continue to hold the shares of such a company. This will benefit both the stake holders.

 

We thank you for your patient reading of this submission.

 

Thanking you and best regards

For India Taxpayer

 

President



Add Comment
Comments
No Comments!
Miranda Hazard Footer

Subscribe for newsletter & updates





Latest News

Board Of Director

Non-resident expats’ salary paid in India won’t face tax

The Authority of Advance Rulings (AAR) has held that the salary income of a nonresident individual for services rendered overseas cannot be taxed in India, even when such salary is paid into a bank account in India. It is not the country of origin, but the number of days’ stay in India, which determine whether a person will be a resident or non-resident for tax purposes. Unlike a tribunal or court order, a ruling by AAR, a quasi-judicial body, does not set a precedent. But it does have persuasive value and is well-considered. Thus, the ruling may benefit expat workers, in particular the over one lakh Indian workers who work in the US, largely on H1B visas.

Contact us


We'd love to hear from you!










By submitting your enquiry you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.