India Taxpayer - India's Independent grassroots movement for better services and lower taxes

+91 422 254 0710

India Tax Payer, No.81, West Venkatasamy Road,R S Puram, Coimbatore - 641 002,Tamilnadu.

India Tax Payer Logo

Merchandise

Forum

Benefits

Resources

News

Event

About Us

  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • BENEFITS
  • RESOURCES
  • NEWS
  • FORUM
  • CONTACT US
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • BENEFITS
  • RESOURCES
  • NEWS
  • FORUM
  • CONTACT US

News & Events

Govt mulls mediation to solve tax issues with companies


The government may adopt a mediation mechanism that will help companies determine their future tax liabilities and even settle disputes, said a person familiar with the development. The concept, which is widely prevalent overseas, is being discussed amid preparations for the February 1 budget, the person said.


Mediation will allow taxpayers to get a fix on how much they need to pay and avoid disputes. “This will bring down litigation substantially,” the person said.

The mediation process involves examining tax legislation and all relevant facts in detail. Neutral mediators, chosen from a panel, will negotiate and arrive at a settlement. The decision is binding on both sides.

The government could also look at expanding the Dispute Resolution Panel mechanism, which handles transfer pricing disputes, as an alternative, the person said.

Currently, the various Authorities for Advance Rulings take up issues from a technical standpoint and do not cover wider issues of law, hence the need for a broader framework. Besides, AAR decisions have not helped in containing litigation as most of these have been getting appealed both by taxpayers as well as the income tax department.


The Companies Act had in 2016 provided for a formal mediation process to settle disputes relating to the law but such a formulation is not present in the Income Tax Act.

The Direct Tax Task Force headed by former Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) member Akhilesh Ranjan had suggested a mechanism to ascertain tax liability.

The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) lobby group has pitched for a mediation mechanism in its pre-budget wish list. It has suggested that the government constitute a panel of experts comprising retired tax officials and experienced professionals to mediate.

“This process saves time and cost and helps in resolving many issues,” said Vasal of Grant Thornton. “The government would also have to provide necessary protection to the revenue or independent authority acting as the mediator from unnecessary questioning and its decisions being challenged in future, to make such a scheme successful.”

The government has sought to partially address this demand in the past through Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) for transfer-pricing cases or by the Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) involving a settlement between the competent authorities of the respective governments, said Rakesh Nangia, chairman, Nangia Andersen Consulting. “Still, the need is felt for a more comprehensive tax-mediation mechanism, where taxpayers can have a dialogue for settlement of their tax disputes in all types of cases.”

Referred from economic times, dated Jan 23 2020

Add Comment
Comments
No Comments!
Miranda Hazard Footer

Subscribe for newsletter & updates





Latest News

Board Of Director

Non-resident expats’ salary paid in India won’t face tax

The Authority of Advance Rulings (AAR) has held that the salary income of a nonresident individual for services rendered overseas cannot be taxed in India, even when such salary is paid into a bank account in India. It is not the country of origin, but the number of days’ stay in India, which determine whether a person will be a resident or non-resident for tax purposes. Unlike a tribunal or court order, a ruling by AAR, a quasi-judicial body, does not set a precedent. But it does have persuasive value and is well-considered. Thus, the ruling may benefit expat workers, in particular the over one lakh Indian workers who work in the US, largely on H1B visas.

Contact us


We'd love to hear from you!










By submitting your enquiry you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.